Home - Blog - Details

Shisha Tobacco Quality Control: Testing Methods, Chemical Analysis And Laboratory Standards

Niven NIE
Niven NIE
General Manager

Shisha Tobacco Quality Control: Testing Methods, Chemical Analysis and Laboratory Standards

Last updated: 3 November 2026

Shisha tobacco, also known as hookah tobacco, waterpipe tobacco or maassel, is a complex tobacco preparation that commonly contains processed tobacco, humectants, sweeteners, flavourings and water.

Unlike many relatively dry tobacco products, modern shisha tobacco often contains substantial quantities of liquid ingredients surrounding the tobacco particles.

This makes analytical testing particularly important and, in some cases, technically challenging.

What does shisha tobacco quality control involve, and how do laboratories test nicotine, moisture, glycerol, sugars and potentially harmful chemicals?

Understanding these measurements is important for tobacco researchers, analytical laboratories, regulatory professionals and industrial quality teams.

This guide examines the principles of shisha tobacco testing, the differences between product and smoke analysis, relevant ISO standards, and the documentation used to evaluate manufacturing consistency.

What Is Shisha Tobacco Quality Control?

Shisha tobacco quality control refers to the systematic evaluation of raw materials, intermediate materials and finished tobacco products against defined specifications.

These evaluations may involve chemical analysis, physical testing, laboratory documentation and manufacturing traceability.

Because shisha tobacco can contain both solid tobacco particles and liquid ingredients, analytical methods must account for its complex composition.

Quality-control programmes may assess:

Nicotine concentration.

Moisture and water content.

Glycerol and propylene glycol.

Sugars and other formulation constituents.

Tobacco-specific nitrosamines.

Selected metals and other contaminants.

Product consistency.

Packaging integrity.

Batch traceability.

Quality control is not the same as a health safety certification.

Even a tobacco product that meets its manufacturer's specifications can produce harmful emissions when smoked.

Why Is Shisha Tobacco Testing Different from Other Tobacco Products?

Modern maassel often contains a substantial liquid fraction.

Scientific research has shown that the proportions of tobacco, humectants and sugars can differ considerably between commercial products.

A presentation at the 2021 CORESTA Smoke Science and Product Technology meeting described analytical results from 30 commercial shisha tobacco brand-styles.

The reported glycerol content ranged from approximately 27% to 70% of sample weight, while propylene glycol and sugar concentrations also varied considerably.

These measurements describe the samples investigated, not universal manufacturing targets or regulatory limits.

The Challenge of a Complex Sample Matrix

A conventional tobacco laboratory method may have been developed for relatively dry tobacco.

However, contemporary shisha can contain tobacco particles surrounded by viscous liquid ingredients.

This difference can affect sample representativeness and analytical performance.

For example, a small sample collected primarily from the liquid portion may not have the same composition as one containing a greater proportion of tobacco particles.

Therefore, a reliable test result depends on appropriate sampling and validated analytical procedures.

1. Nicotine Content Testing

Nicotine is a naturally occurring alkaloid found in tobacco plants.

It is responsible for the addictive properties of tobacco-containing shisha.

Measuring nicotine concentration is an important part of chemical product characterisation.

How Is Nicotine Measured?

Laboratories may use chromatographic methods, including:

High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)

HPLC separates chemical components and can support quantitative nicotine analysis when the method is suitable for the sample matrix.

Gas Chromatography with Flame Ionisation Detection (GC-FID)

GC-FID is another established analytical technique used in tobacco chemistry.

Research published in 2020 examining waterpipe tobacco and its emissions used GC-FID to determine nicotine content in tobacco samples.

What Should a Nicotine Test Report Include?

A useful analytical report should identify:

The material tested.

Its batch or sample identification.

The method used.

Nicotine concentration.

Reporting units.

Relevant analytical uncertainty or limitations.

The basis on which concentration was calculated.

Wet-Weight vs. Dry-Weight Results

A particularly important distinction is whether nicotine is expressed relative to the total moist product or the dry material.

A product containing substantial humectants and moisture has a different mass composition from dry tobacco leaf.

Consequently, two analytical reports may not be directly comparable if they use different reporting bases.

Nicotine concentration should not be estimated from leaf colour, flavour descriptions or terms such as blonde leaf and dark leaf.

2. Moisture and Water Content Analysis

Moisture is a significant physical characteristic of many shisha tobacco products.

However, the terms moisture content and water content are not always analytically interchangeable.

Why Does Moisture Matter?

Water content influences the physical composition of the product and may change during storage.

For research and quality documentation, consistent measurement is important.

Common Analytical Approaches

Karl Fischer Titration

Karl Fischer methods are used to determine water content in suitable materials.

For a complex product such as shisha tobacco, the analytical method must be verified for the relevant sample composition.

Loss on Drying

Loss-on-drying methods measure the mass lost under specified analytical conditions.

However, the lost mass may include volatile components other than water.

Therefore, a loss-on-drying result should not automatically be described as an exact measurement of water content.

Why Is Method Selection Important?

Shisha tobacco contains ingredients with different chemical and physical properties.

Some analytical approaches suitable for other tobacco products may require additional validation when applied to a moist maassel mixture.

Laboratory reports should specify the method rather than simply presenting a moisture percentage without explanation.

3. Glycerol and Propylene Glycol Testing

Glycerol and propylene glycol are humectants found in many commercial waterpipe tobacco formulations.

Their functions relate primarily to moisture retention and other physical characteristics.

Glycerol Analysis

Glycerol, also called glycerine, has the chemical formula C3H8O3.

Its concentration may vary considerably between shisha products.

Analytical methods such as appropriately validated gas chromatography or liquid chromatography can be used to measure glycerol.

Propylene Glycol Analysis

Propylene glycol, with the chemical formula C3H8O2, is another compound used in some waterpipe tobacco products.

Not every formulation contains the same amount.

In some products, it may be absent or present below the quantification capability of a particular analytical method.

Understanding Detection and Quantification Limits

Laboratory results may include abbreviations such as:

LOD: Limit of Detection.

LOQ: Limit of Quantification.

BQL: Below Quantification Limit.

A result below the quantification limit does not necessarily mean that a chemical is completely absent.

It means the method cannot reliably determine its concentration below the specified limit.

Why Humectant Analysis Matters

Research has demonstrated that humectant composition can influence the chemicals generated during waterpipe smoking.

A 2023 experimental study investigating glycerol concentration reported associations between glycerol and selected toxicant emissions, including acrolein.

However, the relationship depended on the characteristics of the tested mixtures.

Glycerol measurement alone cannot establish the safety of a finished waterpipe product.

4. Sugar Content Analysis

Modern maassel commonly contains sugar-based substances.

These may include molasses and other syrups containing compounds such as glucose, fructose and sucrose.

Which Sugars Can Be Analysed?

Laboratory testing may examine:

Glucose.

Fructose.

Sucrose.

Total reducing sugars.

Other carbohydrates, where relevant.

The choice of analytical method depends on the intended measurement.

Why Is Sugar Analysis Challenging?

Sugar-containing ingredients may be present alongside glycerol, propylene glycol, tobacco particles and flavouring substances.

These components create a complex sample matrix.

Different methods may be required to distinguish individual sugars from other compounds.

The CORESTA research on contemporary shisha tobacco highlighted the importance of methods specifically suitable for this type of material.

Natural Tobacco Sugars vs. Added Sugars

Some tobacco types contain naturally occurring sugars.

Commercial shisha may also contain substantial amounts of added sweetening ingredients.

A measured sugar concentration therefore does not necessarily indicate how much sugar originated from the tobacco leaf.

Understanding the distinction may require additional formulation information.

5. Tobacco-Specific Nitrosamine Testing

Tobacco-specific nitrosamines, or TSNAs, are a group of compounds of significant toxicological concern.

Their occurrence can be influenced by tobacco characteristics, curing and processing conditions.

Which Compounds Are Relevant?

Examples of tobacco-specific nitrosamines include:

NNN: N'-Nitrosonornicotine.

NNK: 4-(Methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone.

NAT: N'-Nitrosoanatabine.

NAB: N'-Nitrosoanabasine.

These substances may be included in research and regulatory testing programmes.

How Are TSNAs Measured?

Liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry, commonly called LC-MS/MS, is an established method for analysing selected TSNAs.

The method must be appropriate for the material and the analytical objective.

Do Dark-Leaf Products Always Have Higher TSNAs?

Not necessarily.

Tobacco variety and processing can influence TSNA composition, but the finished-product results depend on the actual material.

A study examining different waterpipe tobacco products found variation related to tobacco composition and other product characteristics.

The findings do not establish a universal TSNA concentration for every blonde-leaf or dark-leaf product.

6. Heavy Metals and Other Contaminants

Tobacco plants can take up certain elements from soil and the surrounding environment.

Consequently, metal analysis may be relevant to tobacco product characterisation.

Examples include:

Lead.

Cadmium.

Arsenic.

Other elements identified as relevant to the analytical assessment.

Laboratory Methods

Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) is commonly used for sensitive elemental analysis.

Research on waterpipe tobacco products has employed ICP-MS to investigate selected metals.

Why Are Product and Smoke Measurements Different?

The concentration of a metal in unheated tobacco does not directly establish the quantity transferred into inhaled smoke.

Smoke emissions can also be affected by charcoal and other components of the waterpipe system.

Therefore, testing the original product and testing generated emissions answer different scientific questions.

7. Waterpipe Smoke Emissions Testing

Finished-product testing can determine what substances are present before a product is heated.

Smoke emissions testing investigates chemical substances generated or transferred during waterpipe use under specified laboratory conditions.

These measurements should not be confused.

What Can Emissions Testing Measure?

Depending on the analytical study, selected emissions may include:

Nicotine.

Carbon monoxide.

Carbonyl compounds.

Particulate matter or total collected matter.

Tobacco-specific nitrosamines.

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.

Selected metals.

Other potentially harmful constituents.

ISO 22486:2019

ISO 22486:2019 is titled Water pipe tobacco smoking machine - Definitions and standard conditions.

It specifies standard conditions for routine analytical machine smoking of waterpipe tobacco using electrical heating.

The standard was reviewed and confirmed in 2025.

An important limitation is that its defined test conditions do not reproduce every form of real-world waterpipe use.

In particular, the standard concerns electrically heated tobacco rather than charcoal-heated smoking sessions.

ISO/TS 22487:2019

ISO/TS 22487:2019 is titled Water pipe tobacco - Determination of total collected matter and nicotine using a water pipe tobacco smoking machine.

It addresses the determination of total collected matter and nicotine in smoke generated and collected under the relevant machine-smoking conditions.

The specification provides a standardised analytical approach.

However, these measurements should not be interpreted as a complete assessment of human exposure or product safety.

8. Laboratory Method Validation

A laboratory method must be suitable for its intended purpose.

This is particularly important when analysing shisha tobacco because of its unusual material composition.

Relevant validation characteristics may include:

Accuracy.

Precision.

Selectivity.

Analytical sensitivity.

Quantification limits.

Measurement uncertainty.

Repeatability.

Sample-matrix effects.

A method developed for dry tobacco should not automatically be assumed to perform identically with a highly moist maassel preparation.

ISO/IEC 17025

ISO/IEC 17025:2017 establishes general requirements for the competence, impartiality and consistent operation of testing and calibration laboratories.

Accreditation against this standard can provide confidence in a laboratory's demonstrated technical capabilities.

However, accreditation must be considered in relation to the laboratory's specific accredited scope.

A laboratory's accreditation does not mean that every test it offers is necessarily covered by that accreditation.

Nor does ISO/IEC 17025 certify that a tobacco product is safe.

9. Batch-to-Batch Consistency

Industrial quality management also concerns variation between manufacturing batches.

Because tobacco is an agricultural material, differences can arise from raw-material characteristics.

Additional variation may be associated with the composition and handling of the finished mixture.

What Is Batch Consistency?

Batch consistency describes the degree to which separate production lots meet established product specifications.

Relevant characteristics may include nicotine concentration, moisture, selected ingredient concentrations, physical properties and packaging condition.

Why Is Traceability Important?

Traceability helps connect an individual batch with its associated manufacturing and quality records.

This can support:

Investigation of unexpected test results.

Identification of affected production lots.

Assessment of material changes.

Documentation of relevant quality decisions.

Regulatory reporting where required.

A batch may appear visually consistent while differing in chemical composition.

Analytical evidence is therefore an important complement to visual inspection.

10. Packaging Integrity and Storage Stability

Packaging can influence the physical condition of a moist tobacco preparation during storage.

Relevant assessments may consider seal integrity, packaging compatibility, weight changes and alterations in chemical composition.

Stability Assessment

Stability investigations may examine whether selected product characteristics change over time.

The appropriate programme depends on the material and its intended regulatory requirements.

Packaging Identification

Relevant documentation can include batch codes, product identity and applicable warning labels.

Because tobacco regulations vary across countries, packaging that complies in one market may not be acceptable in another.

Product quality records do not replace legally required health warnings or market authorisations.

11. Certificates of Analysis for Shisha Tobacco

A Certificate of Analysis, or COA, can provide analytical information about a particular material or production batch.

The appropriate contents depend on the product, analytical programme and applicable legal requirements.

A COA may include:

Product Identification

A clear description of the tested material.

Batch Number

A traceable reference connecting the test results to a specific lot.

Analytical Parameters

The measured characteristics, such as nicotine or selected chemical constituents.

Test Results

The laboratory's reported measurements and appropriate units.

Test Methods

The procedures or standards used to produce the results.

Specifications

The applicable comparison criteria, where established.

Responsible Laboratory

Information identifying the organisation responsible for the testing.

A COA should be evaluated alongside the supporting analytical methods and the intended use of the information.

It does not constitute proof of health safety or automatic permission to import or sell tobacco products.

12. International Regulatory Considerations

Waterpipe tobacco is regulated differently across countries.

Relevant obligations may involve:

Ingredient reporting.

Product registration or authorisation.

Import controls.

Health warning requirements.

Standardised packaging.

Tobacco taxation.

Advertising restrictions.

Age-of-sale regulations.

United States

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration regulates hookah tobacco as a tobacco product.

Applicable requirements may include ingredient listing, product registration and listing, marketing authorisation and other regulatory obligations.

A quality-control report does not replace these requirements.

International Markets

Other jurisdictions may apply different technical and commercial rules.

There is no single universal testing certificate that automatically establishes legal market access in every country.

For international research or regulatory assessment, local requirements must be reviewed individually.

13. Does Quality Testing Make Shisha Tobacco Safe?

No.

This is one of the most important distinctions in tobacco product science.

Quality-control testing measures selected characteristics of a material or product.

It does not eliminate the toxic substances generated during waterpipe smoking.

According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, hookah smoke contains nicotine, carbon monoxide, heavy metals and carcinogenic chemicals.

The charcoal used to heat tobacco can contribute additional hazardous emissions.

Water does not remove these major toxicants.

Consequently, a laboratory-tested shisha tobacco product can still present serious risks of addiction, cardiovascular disease, respiratory illness and cancer.

Accurate analytical documentation should never be used to imply that smoking tobacco is harmless.

Frequently Asked Questions About Shisha Tobacco Quality Control

1. What is shisha tobacco quality control?

Shisha tobacco quality control involves testing and documentation used to characterise raw materials, finished products and manufacturing consistency against defined specifications.

2. How is nicotine content measured in shisha tobacco?

Suitable analytical techniques include HPLC and GC-FID. The method must be validated for the relevant sample matrix and measurement objective.

3. Why is shisha tobacco moisture testing important?

Moisture is a significant characteristic of many maassel products. Its measurement helps describe product composition and assess changes during storage.

4. How are glycerol and propylene glycol tested?

Appropriate chromatographic methods can be used to measure these humectants. Results depend on the analytical method and sample characteristics.

5. Can laboratories test the sugar content of shisha tobacco?

Yes. Analytical methods can determine selected sugars, including glucose, fructose and sucrose, when suitable procedures are used.

6. What are tobacco-specific nitrosamines?

TSNAs are tobacco-related chemical compounds of toxicological concern. Selected TSNAs can be measured using methods such as LC-MS/MS.

7. What is ISO 22486?

ISO 22486:2019 defines standard conditions for routine machine smoking of electrically heated waterpipe tobacco for analytical purposes.

8. What is the difference between tobacco testing and smoke testing?

Tobacco testing measures characteristics of the original material. Smoke testing investigates compounds generated or transferred during heating under defined conditions.

9. Does ISO/IEC 17025 certify that shisha tobacco is safe?

No. ISO/IEC 17025 concerns laboratory competence. It does not certify the health safety of tobacco products.

10. Does a Certificate of Analysis establish import eligibility?

No. A COA reports selected analytical results. Import and sale permissions depend on the laws of the destination country.

Conclusion

Shisha tobacco quality control requires an understanding of chemical analysis, complex sample composition, manufacturing consistency and relevant laboratory standards.

Unlike many relatively dry tobacco products, contemporary maassel can contain substantial quantities of glycerol, propylene glycol, sugars and other ingredients alongside processed tobacco.

This composition creates analytical challenges, particularly when obtaining representative samples and interpreting results from methods developed for other tobacco matrices.

Nicotine, water content, humectants, sugars, selected nitrosamines and metals may all be relevant to product characterisation.

International standards such as ISO 22486 and ISO/TS 22487 also provide defined approaches for selected waterpipe smoke measurements.

However, chemical product testing and smoke emissions testing serve different purposes.

Neither establishes that waterpipe tobacco is safe.

For laboratories, researchers, regulators and industrial quality professionals, the most reliable approach is to use scientifically appropriate analytical methods, transparent reporting and traceable documentation.

Further Reading

Explore our related technical guides on shisha tobacco ingredients, manufacturing principles, Virginia versus dark-leaf tobacco, smoke chemistry and international waterpipe tobacco regulations.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for scientific, technical and regulatory education only. It does not constitute a product certification, laboratory protocol or endorsement of tobacco use. Shisha tobacco contains addictive nicotine, and waterpipe smoking can cause serious health effects.

Send Inquiry

You Might Also Like